STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — For the fourth time in “Best of Staten Island” history, Heartland Bagels in New Springville has secured the title of “Best Bagel Store.”

During our most recent poll, the kosher bagel store racked up 7,896 votes while competing against Mikey Bagels in Tottenville and Bagels R Us in Eltingville.

“The honor really goes to my customers and the staff that work here,” said Anthony Teutonico, owner of Heartland Bagels and its sister location, Heartland Bagels 2, in Rossville. “I wouldn’t be anywhere without them.”